Even though Sammy and his tennis instructor advise against it, Pauly plans to go through with his idea of catering The Comedy Store with the roach coach. (Previously in the episode Love & Limos, Pauly gave Mark Hatchell $1500 to find a caterer and Mark came back with tacos on wheels.)
In order to push the food and drinks, he also wants to hire hot waitresses. After interviewing several potential candidates with Dean, they settle on Ashley, a cute blonde with absolutely no experience. However, Pauly's decision doesn't sit well with the longstanding waitstaff of The Store. Instead of firing her, however, Pauly promotes Ashley to the front bar.
Undermanned and underprepared, The Comedy Store is slammed with customers who actually love the food, but there are not enough waitresses and comics to serve it. Pauly stumbles through yet another good idea gone awry.