Pauly's agents tell him that if he seriously wants to be a dramatic actor, he needs a tape that they can use to showcase his talents, so he decides to remake a scene from one of his favorite movies, Black Godfather.

Pauly runs a few lines with Marlon and enlists him to be propmaster for the shoot. At The Comedy Store, Dean alerts Pauly of a few fixes that need to be made, including remodeling the front bar. While Pauly works with Tommy on the Godfather scene, Marlon is hard at work, visiting gun stores and costume shops for the perfect pimp hat. Pauly decides to shoot the scene in the main room of the Comedy Store, but amidst the heavy construction of the front bar, it's difficult for him to concentrate and focus.

After shooting the scene, Pauly returns to his agents who laugh at the tape. However, the new bar is a huge success and although Pauly's attempt to redefine his career took a big blow, at least managing The Comedy Store is working out...for now.